Install coolbits if using nvidia, add preserve video memory install script

12 files changed, 113 insertions, 36 deletions

diff --git a/88-gsr-coolbits.conf b/88-gsr-coolbits.conf
index be665f1..2a9055c 100644
--- a/88-gsr-coolbits.conf
+++ b/88-gsr-coolbits.conf
@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 Section "Device"
-    Identifier     "Device0"
+    Identifier     "NvidiaCoolbits"
     Driver         "nvidia"
     Option         "Coolbits" "12"
 EndSection
diff --git a/README.md b/README.md
index 929a8ed..6f6568b 100644
--- a/README.md
+++ b/README.md
@@ -15,12 +15,14 @@ and then rebooting your laptop.
 screen-direct capture has been temporary disabled as it causes issues with stuttering. This might be a nvfbc bug.
 
 # Performance
+On a system with a i5 4690k CPU and a GTX 1080 GPU:\
 When recording Legend of Zelda Breath of the Wild at 4k, fps drops from 30 to 7 when using OBS Studio + nvenc, however when using this screen recorder the fps remains at 30.\
 When recording GTA V at 4k on highest settings, fps drops from 60 to 23 when using obs-nvfbc + nvenc, however when using this screen recorder the fps only drops to 58. The quality is also much better when using gpu-screen-recorder.\
-It is recommended to save the video to a SSD because of the large file size, which a slow HDD might not be fast enough to handle.
+It is recommended to save the video to a SSD because of the large file size, which a slow HDD might not be fast enough to handle.\
+Note that if you have a very powerful CPU and a not so powerful GPU and play a game that is bottlenecked by your GPU and barely uses your CPU then a CPU based screen recording (such as OBS with libx264 instead of nvenc) might perform slightly better than GPU Screen Recorder. At least on NVIDIA.
 ## Note about optimal performance on NVIDIA
 NVIDIA driver has a "feature" (read: bug) where it will downclock memory transfer rate when a program uses cuda, such as GPU Screen Recorder. To work around this bug, GPU Screen Recorder can overclock your GPU memory transfer rate to it's normal optimal level.\
-To enable overclocking for optimal performance use the `-oc` option when running GPU Screen Recorder. You also need to have "Coolbits" NVIDIA X setting set to "12" to enable overclocking. You can automatically add this option if you run `install_coolbits.sh` and then reboot your computer.\
+To enable overclocking for optimal performance use the `-oc` option when running GPU Screen Recorder. You also need to have "Coolbits" NVIDIA X setting set to "12" to enable overclocking. You can automatically add this option if you run `install_coolbits.sh` and then reboot your computer. This script is automatically run if you are using NVIDIA and run `install.sh`.\
 Note that this only works when Xorg server is running as root, and using this option will only give you a performance boost if the game you are recording is bottlenecked by your GPU.\
 Note! use at your own risk!
 
@@ -53,6 +55,10 @@ There is also a gui for the gpu-screen-recorder called [gpu-screen-recorder-gtk]
 Run the script `scripts/start-replay.sh` to start replay and then `scripts/save-replay.sh` to save a replay and `scripts/stop-replay.sh` to stop the replay. The videos are saved to `$HOME/Videos`.
 You can use these scripts to start replay at system startup if you add `scripts/start-replay.sh` to startup (this can be done differently depending on your desktop environment / window manager) and then go into hotkey settings on your system and choose a hotkey to run the script `scripts/save-replay.sh`. Modify `scripts/start-replay.sh` if you want to use other replay options.
 
+## Issues
+### NVIDIA
+Nvidia drivers have an issue where CUDA breaks if CUDA is running when suspend/hibernation happens, and it remains broken until you reload the nvidia driver. To fix this, either disable suspend or tell the NVIDIA driver to preserve video memory on suspend/hibernate by using the `NVreg_PreserveVideoMemoryAllocations=1` option. You can run `install_preserve_video_memory.sh` to automatically add that option to your system.
+
 # Demo
 [![Click here to watch a demo video on youtube](https://img.youtube.com/vi/n5tm0g01n6A/0.jpg)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n5tm0g01n6A)
 
diff --git a/TODO b/TODO
index 12de328..7f330f3 100644
--- a/TODO
+++ b/TODO
@@ -28,3 +28,8 @@ Test different combinations of switchable graphics. Intel hybrid mode (running i
 
 https://web.archive.org/web/20210306020203/https://forums.developer.nvidia.com/t/performance-power-management-problem-on-shared-vgpu/161986
 https://djdallmann.github.io/GamingPCSetup/CONTENT/RESEARCH/FINDINGS/registrykeys_displayadapter_class_4d36e968-e325-11ce-bfc1-08002be10318.txt
+
+The video output will be black if if the system is suspended on nvidia and NVreg_PreserveVideoMemoryAllocations is not set to 1. This happens because I think that the driver invalidates textures/cuda buffers? To fix this we could try and recreate gsr capture when gsr_capture_capture fails (with timeout to retry again).
+
+NVreg_RegistryDwords.
+Restore nvfbc screen recording on monitor reconfiguration.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/gsr-nvidia.conf b/gsr-nvidia.conf
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..10cbf7d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/gsr-nvidia.conf
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+options nvidia NVreg_PreserveVideoMemoryAllocations=1
diff --git a/include/xnvctrl.h b/include/xnvctrl.h
index 8e026c4..33fc442 100644
--- a/include/xnvctrl.h
+++ b/include/xnvctrl.h
@@ -4,7 +4,9 @@
 #include <stdbool.h>
 #include <stdint.h>
 
+#define NV_CTRL_GPU_NVCLOCK_OFFSET                                      409
 #define NV_CTRL_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE_OFFSET                            410
+#define NV_CTRL_GPU_NVCLOCK_OFFSET_ALL_PERFORMANCE_LEVELS               424
 #define NV_CTRL_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE_OFFSET_ALL_PERFORMANCE_LEVELS     425
 
 #define NV_CTRL_TARGET_TYPE_GPU                                         1
diff --git a/install.sh b/install.sh
index 014223d..aa4c802 100755
--- a/install.sh
+++ b/install.sh
@@ -9,4 +9,5 @@ cd "$script_dir"
 install -Dm755 "gpu-screen-recorder" "/usr/local/bin/gpu-screen-recorder"
 install -Dm755 "gpu-screen-recorder" "/usr/bin/gpu-screen-recorder"
 
+[ -f "/proc/driver/nvidia/version" ] && ./install_coolbits.sh
 echo "Successfully installed gpu-screen-recorder"
diff --git a/install_coolbits.sh b/install_coolbits.sh
index 0ce4c28..053e8ab 100755
--- a/install_coolbits.sh
+++ b/install_coolbits.sh
@@ -6,5 +6,5 @@ cd "$script_dir"
 [ $(id -u) -ne 0 ] && echo "You need root privileges to run the install script" && exit 1
 
 for xorg_conf_d in "/etc/X11/xorg.conf.d" "/usr/share/X11/xorg.conf.d" "/usr/lib/X11/xorg.conf.d"; do
-    [ -d "$xorg_conf_d" ] && install -Dm644 "88-gsr-coolbits.conf" "$xorg_conf_d/88-gsr-coolbits.conf"
-done
\ No newline at end of file
+    [ -d "$xorg_conf_d" ] && install -Dm644 "88-gsr-coolbits.conf" "$xorg_conf_d/88-gsr-coolbits.conf" && exit 0
+done
diff --git a/install_preserve_video_memory.sh b/install_preserve_video_memory.sh
new file mode 100755
index 0000000..c5cf658
--- /dev/null
+++ b/install_preserve_video_memory.sh
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
+#!/bin/sh
+
+script_dir=$(dirname "$0")
+cd "$script_dir"
+
+[ $(id -u) -ne 0 ] && echo "You need root privileges to run the install script" && exit 1
+
+install -Dm644 gsr-nvidia.conf /etc/modprobe.d/gsr-nvidia.conf
diff --git a/src/capture/nvfbc.c b/src/capture/nvfbc.c
index c1c998b..d538b5b 100644
--- a/src/capture/nvfbc.c
+++ b/src/capture/nvfbc.c
@@ -20,6 +20,7 @@ typedef struct {
     PNVFBCCREATEINSTANCE nv_fbc_create_instance;
     NVFBC_API_FUNCTION_LIST nv_fbc_function_list;
     bool fbc_handle_created;
+    bool capture_session_created;
 
     gsr_cuda cuda;
     bool frame_initialized;
@@ -225,9 +226,9 @@ static int gsr_capture_nvfbc_start(gsr_capture *cap, AVCodecContext *video_codec
 
     NVFBCSTATUS status;
     NVFBC_TRACKING_TYPE tracking_type;
-    bool capture_session_created = false;
     uint32_t output_id = 0;
     cap_nvfbc->fbc_handle_created = false;
+    cap_nvfbc->capture_session_created = false;
 
     NVFBC_CREATE_HANDLE_PARAMS create_params;
     memset(&create_params, 0, sizeof(create_params));
@@ -295,6 +296,7 @@ static int gsr_capture_nvfbc_start(gsr_capture *cap, AVCodecContext *video_codec
     create_capture_params.dwSamplingRateMs = 1000u / ((uint32_t)cap_nvfbc->params.fps + 1);
     create_capture_params.bAllowDirectCapture = direct_capture ? NVFBC_TRUE : NVFBC_FALSE;
     create_capture_params.bPushModel = direct_capture ? NVFBC_TRUE : NVFBC_FALSE;
+    //create_capture_params.bDisableAutoModesetRecovery = true; // TODO:
     if(tracking_type == NVFBC_TRACKING_OUTPUT)
         create_capture_params.dwOutputId = output_id;
 
@@ -303,7 +305,7 @@ static int gsr_capture_nvfbc_start(gsr_capture *cap, AVCodecContext *video_codec
         fprintf(stderr, "gsr error: gsr_capture_nvfbc_start failed: %s\n", cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_function_list.nvFBCGetLastErrorStr(cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_handle));
         goto error_cleanup;
     }
-    capture_session_created = true;
+    cap_nvfbc->capture_session_created = true;
 
     NVFBC_TOCUDA_SETUP_PARAMS setup_params;
     memset(&setup_params, 0, sizeof(setup_params));
@@ -331,11 +333,12 @@ static int gsr_capture_nvfbc_start(gsr_capture *cap, AVCodecContext *video_codec
 
     error_cleanup:
     if(cap_nvfbc->fbc_handle_created) {
-        if(capture_session_created) {
+        if(cap_nvfbc->capture_session_created) {
             NVFBC_DESTROY_CAPTURE_SESSION_PARAMS destroy_capture_params;
             memset(&destroy_capture_params, 0, sizeof(destroy_capture_params));
             destroy_capture_params.dwVersion = NVFBC_DESTROY_CAPTURE_SESSION_PARAMS_VER;
             cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_function_list.nvFBCDestroyCaptureSession(cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_handle, &destroy_capture_params);
+            cap_nvfbc->capture_session_created = false;
         }
 
         NVFBC_DESTROY_HANDLE_PARAMS destroy_params;
@@ -357,15 +360,21 @@ static int gsr_capture_nvfbc_start(gsr_capture *cap, AVCodecContext *video_codec
 static void gsr_capture_nvfbc_destroy_session(gsr_capture *cap) {
     gsr_capture_nvfbc *cap_nvfbc = cap->priv;
 
-    NVFBC_DESTROY_CAPTURE_SESSION_PARAMS destroy_capture_params;
-    memset(&destroy_capture_params, 0, sizeof(destroy_capture_params));
-    destroy_capture_params.dwVersion = NVFBC_DESTROY_CAPTURE_SESSION_PARAMS_VER;
-    cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_function_list.nvFBCDestroyCaptureSession(cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_handle, &destroy_capture_params);
+    if(cap_nvfbc->fbc_handle_created) {
+        if(cap_nvfbc->capture_session_created) {
+            NVFBC_DESTROY_CAPTURE_SESSION_PARAMS destroy_capture_params;
+            memset(&destroy_capture_params, 0, sizeof(destroy_capture_params));
+            destroy_capture_params.dwVersion = NVFBC_DESTROY_CAPTURE_SESSION_PARAMS_VER;
+            cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_function_list.nvFBCDestroyCaptureSession(cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_handle, &destroy_capture_params);
+            cap_nvfbc->capture_session_created = false;
+        }
 
-    NVFBC_DESTROY_HANDLE_PARAMS destroy_params;
-    memset(&destroy_params, 0, sizeof(destroy_params));
-    destroy_params.dwVersion = NVFBC_DESTROY_HANDLE_PARAMS_VER;
-    cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_function_list.nvFBCDestroyHandle(cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_handle, &destroy_params);
+        NVFBC_DESTROY_HANDLE_PARAMS destroy_params;
+        memset(&destroy_params, 0, sizeof(destroy_params));
+        destroy_params.dwVersion = NVFBC_DESTROY_HANDLE_PARAMS_VER;
+        cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_function_list.nvFBCDestroyHandle(cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_handle, &destroy_params);
+        cap_nvfbc->fbc_handle_created = false;
+    }
 
     cap_nvfbc->nv_fbc_handle = 0;
 }
diff --git a/src/cuda.c b/src/cuda.c
index 470747b..ea14e8b 100644
--- a/src/cuda.c
+++ b/src/cuda.c
@@ -94,6 +94,11 @@ bool gsr_cuda_load(gsr_cuda *self, Display *display, bool do_overclock) {
 }
 
 void gsr_cuda_unload(gsr_cuda *self) {
+    if(self->do_overclock && self->overclock.xnvctrl.library) {
+        gsr_overclock_stop(&self->overclock);
+        gsr_overclock_unload(&self->overclock);
+    }
+
     if(self->library) {
         if(self->cu_ctx) {
             self->cuCtxDestroy_v2(self->cu_ctx);
@@ -102,10 +107,5 @@ void gsr_cuda_unload(gsr_cuda *self) {
         dlclose(self->library);
     }
 
-    if(self->do_overclock && self->overclock.xnvctrl.library) {
-        gsr_overclock_stop(&self->overclock);
-        gsr_overclock_unload(&self->overclock);
-    }
-
     memset(self, 0, sizeof(gsr_cuda));
 }
diff --git a/src/main.cpp b/src/main.cpp
index 36fcfe5..4cd8682 100644
--- a/src/main.cpp
+++ b/src/main.cpp
@@ -659,7 +659,7 @@ static void open_video(AVCodecContext *codec_context, VideoQuality video_quality
 }
 
 static void usage() {
-    fprintf(stderr, "usage: gpu-screen-recorder -w <window_id|monitor|focused> [-c <container_format>] [-s WxH] -f <fps> [-a <audio_input>...] [-q <quality>] [-r <replay_buffer_size_sec>] [-k h264|h265] [-ac aac|opus|flac] [-oc yes|no] [-o <output_file>]\n");
+    fprintf(stderr, "usage: gpu-screen-recorder -w <window_id|monitor|focused> [-c <container_format>] [-s WxH] -f <fps> [-a <audio_input>] [-q <quality>] [-r <replay_buffer_size_sec>] [-k h264|h265] [-ac aac|opus|flac] [-oc yes|no] [-o <output_file>]\n");
     fprintf(stderr, "\n");
     fprintf(stderr, "OPTIONS:\n");
     fprintf(stderr, "  -w    Window to record, a display, \"screen\", \"screen-direct\", \"screen-direct-force\" or \"focused\".\n");
@@ -2005,6 +2005,7 @@ int main(int argc, char **argv) {
             frame_time_overflow = std::min(frame_time_overflow, target_fps);
             frame_timer_start = time_now - frame_time_overflow;
             gsr_capture_capture(capture, frame);
+
             std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(video_frame_mutex);
             if(latest_video_frame) {
                 av_frame_free(&latest_video_frame);
diff --git a/src/overclock.c b/src/overclock.c
index 8517876..7c0faad 100644
--- a/src/overclock.c
+++ b/src/overclock.c
@@ -8,10 +8,12 @@
 // So to get around this we overclock memory transfer rate (maybe this should also be done for graphics clock?) to the best performance level while GPU Screen Recorder is running.
 
 // TODO: Does it always drop to performance level 2?
-// TODO: Also do the same for graphics clock and graphics memory?
 
-// Fields are 0 if not set
+static int min_int(int a, int b) {
+    return a < b ? a : b;
+}
 
+// Fields are 0 if not set
 typedef struct {
     int perf;
 
@@ -48,31 +50,56 @@ static void split_by_delimiter(const char *str, size_t size, char delimiter, spl
     }
 }
 
+typedef enum {
+    NVCTRL_GPU_NVCLOCK,
+    NVCTRL_ATTRIB_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE,
+} NvCTRLAttributeType;
+
+static unsigned int attribute_type_to_attribute_param(NvCTRLAttributeType attribute_type) {
+    switch(attribute_type) {
+        case NVCTRL_GPU_NVCLOCK:
+            return NV_CTRL_GPU_NVCLOCK_OFFSET;
+        case NVCTRL_ATTRIB_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE:
+            return NV_CTRL_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE_OFFSET;
+    }
+    return 0;
+}
+
+static unsigned int attribute_type_to_attribute_param_all_levels(NvCTRLAttributeType attribute_type) {
+    switch(attribute_type) {
+        case NVCTRL_GPU_NVCLOCK:
+            return NV_CTRL_GPU_NVCLOCK_OFFSET_ALL_PERFORMANCE_LEVELS;
+        case NVCTRL_ATTRIB_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE:
+            return NV_CTRL_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE_OFFSET_ALL_PERFORMANCE_LEVELS;
+    }
+    return 0;
+}
+
 // Returns 0 on error
-static int xnvctrl_get_memory_transfer_rate_max(gsr_xnvctrl *xnvctrl, const NVCTRLPerformanceLevelQuery *query) {
+static int xnvctrl_get_attribute_max_value(gsr_xnvctrl *xnvctrl, const NVCTRLPerformanceLevelQuery *query, NvCTRLAttributeType attribute_type) {
     NVCTRLAttributeValidValuesRec valid;
-    if(xnvctrl->XNVCTRLQueryValidTargetAttributeValues(xnvctrl->display, NV_CTRL_TARGET_TYPE_GPU, 0, 0, NV_CTRL_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE_OFFSET_ALL_PERFORMANCE_LEVELS, &valid)) {
+    if(xnvctrl->XNVCTRLQueryValidTargetAttributeValues(xnvctrl->display, NV_CTRL_TARGET_TYPE_GPU, 0, 0, attribute_type_to_attribute_param_all_levels(attribute_type), &valid)) {
         return valid.u.range.max;
     }
 
-    if(query->num_performance_levels > 0 && xnvctrl->XNVCTRLQueryValidTargetAttributeValues(xnvctrl->display, NV_CTRL_TARGET_TYPE_GPU, 0, query->num_performance_levels - 1, NV_CTRL_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE_OFFSET, &valid)) {
+    if(query->num_performance_levels > 0 && xnvctrl->XNVCTRLQueryValidTargetAttributeValues(xnvctrl->display, NV_CTRL_TARGET_TYPE_GPU, 0, query->num_performance_levels - 1, attribute_type_to_attribute_param(attribute_type), &valid)) {
         return valid.u.range.max;
     }
     
     return 0;
 }
 
-static bool xnvctrl_set_memory_transfer_rate_offset(gsr_xnvctrl *xnvctrl, int num_performance_levels, int offset) {
+static bool xnvctrl_set_attribute_offset(gsr_xnvctrl *xnvctrl, int num_performance_levels, int offset, NvCTRLAttributeType attribute_type) {
     bool success = false;
 
     // NV_CTRL_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE_OFFSET_ALL_PERFORMANCE_LEVELS works (or at least used to?) without Xorg running as root
     // so we try that first. NV_CTRL_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE_OFFSET_ALL_PERFORMANCE_LEVELS also only works with GTX 1000+.
     // TODO: Reverse engineer NVIDIA Xorg driver so we can set this always without root access.
-    if(xnvctrl->XNVCTRLSetTargetAttributeAndGetStatus(xnvctrl->display, NV_CTRL_TARGET_TYPE_GPU, 0, 0, NV_CTRL_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE_OFFSET_ALL_PERFORMANCE_LEVELS, offset))
+    if(xnvctrl->XNVCTRLSetTargetAttributeAndGetStatus(xnvctrl->display, NV_CTRL_TARGET_TYPE_GPU, 0, 0, attribute_type_to_attribute_param_all_levels(attribute_type), offset))
         success = true;
 
     for(int i = 0; i < num_performance_levels; ++i) {
-        success |= xnvctrl->XNVCTRLSetTargetAttributeAndGetStatus(xnvctrl->display, NV_CTRL_TARGET_TYPE_GPU, 0, i, NV_CTRL_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE_OFFSET, offset);
+        success |= xnvctrl->XNVCTRLSetTargetAttributeAndGetStatus(xnvctrl->display, NV_CTRL_TARGET_TYPE_GPU, 0, i, attribute_type_to_attribute_param(attribute_type), offset);
     }
 
     return success;
@@ -207,21 +234,38 @@ bool gsr_overclock_start(gsr_overclock *self) {
     }
     self->num_performance_levels = query.num_performance_levels;
 
-    int target_transfer_rate_offset = xnvctrl_get_memory_transfer_rate_max(&self->xnvctrl, &query) / 2;
-    if(query.num_performance_levels > 3) {
+    int target_transfer_rate_offset = xnvctrl_get_attribute_max_value(&self->xnvctrl, &query, NVCTRL_ATTRIB_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE) / 2; // Divide by 2 just to be safe that we dont set it too high
+    if(query.num_performance_levels > 2) {
         const int transfer_rate_max_diff = query.performance_level[query.num_performance_levels - 1].mem_transfer_rate_max - query.performance_level[2].mem_transfer_rate_max;
-        if(transfer_rate_max_diff > 0 && transfer_rate_max_diff < target_transfer_rate_offset)
-            target_transfer_rate_offset = transfer_rate_max_diff;
+        target_transfer_rate_offset = min_int(target_transfer_rate_offset, transfer_rate_max_diff);
     }
 
-    if(xnvctrl_set_memory_transfer_rate_offset(&self->xnvctrl, self->num_performance_levels, target_transfer_rate_offset)) {
+    if(xnvctrl_set_attribute_offset(&self->xnvctrl, self->num_performance_levels, target_transfer_rate_offset, NVCTRL_ATTRIB_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE)) {
         fprintf(stderr, "gsr info: gsr_overclock_start: sucessfully set memory transfer rate offset to %d\n", target_transfer_rate_offset);
     } else {
         fprintf(stderr, "gsr info: gsr_overclock_start: failed to overclock memory transfer rate offset to %d\n", target_transfer_rate_offset);
     }
+
+
+    // TODO: Enable. Crashes on my system (gtx 1080) so it's disabled for now. Seems to crash even if graphics clock is increasd by 1, let alone 1200
+    /*
+    int target_nv_clock_offset = xnvctrl_get_attribute_max_value(&self->xnvctrl, &query, NVCTRL_GPU_NVCLOCK) / 2; // Divide by 2 just to be safe that we dont set it too high
+    if(query.num_performance_levels > 2) {
+        const int nv_clock_max_diff = query.performance_level[query.num_performance_levels - 1].nv_clock_max - query.performance_level[2].nv_clock_max;
+        target_nv_clock_offset = min_int(target_nv_clock_offset, nv_clock_max_diff);
+    }
+
+    if(xnvctrl_set_attribute_offset(&self->xnvctrl, self->num_performance_levels, target_nv_clock_offset, NVCTRL_GPU_NVCLOCK)) {
+        fprintf(stderr, "gsr info: gsr_overclock_start: sucessfully set nv clock offset to %d\n", target_nv_clock_offset);
+    } else {
+        fprintf(stderr, "gsr info: gsr_overclock_start: failed to overclock nv clock offset to %d\n", target_nv_clock_offset);
+    }
+    */
+
     return true;
 }
 
 void gsr_overclock_stop(gsr_overclock *self) {
-    xnvctrl_set_memory_transfer_rate_offset(&self->xnvctrl, self->num_performance_levels, 0);
+    xnvctrl_set_attribute_offset(&self->xnvctrl, self->num_performance_levels, 0, NVCTRL_ATTRIB_GPU_MEM_TRANSFER_RATE);
+    //xnvctrl_set_attribute_offset(&self->xnvctrl, self->num_performance_levels, 0, NVCTRL_GPU_NVCLOCK);
 }